EV Editor
Member
| Joined: | Mon Nov 5th, 2007 |
| Location: | |
| Posts: | 376 |
| Status: |
Offline
|
back to top
|
Making the connection
East Mesa transit success hinges on system links
By Terrance Thornton
Independent Newspapers
Depending on where you are in the East Valley, the word "transportation" takes on a distinct meaning because each region faces different issues when it comes to people moving around.
In Apache Junction, transportation means maintaining existing infrastructure and if a housing development occurs south of U.S. 60 then the possibility of mass-transit services may come to fruition, city of Apache Junction leaders say.
In Mesa, looking at the next step of transportation — light rail, commuter rail and bus-rapid transit — is what the word "transportation" means to that municipality, Mayor Scott Smith says.
In Queen Creek, investments to existing infrastructure and maintaining the flow of traffic are the focus of leaders still fighting to keep pace with the recent explosion of population, they say.
Maricopa County
The biggest issue facing transportation in Maricopa County is funding, according to Eric Anderson, Maricopa Association of Governments transportation director.
In 2005, Maricopa County voters renewed a half-cent sales tax put on retail purchases to provide for funding transportation and transit projects for the next 20 years, according to http://www.mag.maricopa.gov.
MAG is a council of governments serving as the regional agency for the metropolitan Phoenix area, according to its Web site.
But the problem is folks are spending less and less — especially over the last two years, Mr. Anderson says.
"This fiscal year we are, right now, down 14.5 percent compared to the first months of last year," he explained. "We are kind of in uncharted territories."
In fiscal year 2007-08, MAG collected $380 million in sales-tax revenues dedicated to transportation projects in Maricopa County, Mr. Anderson said.
Mr. Anderson says MAG hopes to collect between $310 million to $315 million this fiscal year.
"We are seeing cuts to transportation services across the board," he explained adding that no cuts have been announced, but he contends they are coming. "The transit programs are being looked at right now."
Mr. Anderson says all projects future and current are being reevaluated.
"Those adjustments are going to include a significant delay to hitting the streets," he said. "We have had to delay many projects across the region."
Mesa
"If we are talking transportation, for a lot of people, it means highways," said Mayor Scott Smith in a Dec. 9 phone interview. "In Mesa, since freeways are finished, it means for us looking at the next chapter."
The next chapter for the city of Mesa is extending light rail through downtown, the usage of bus-rapid transit and the evolution of traditional bus routes, Mayor Smith says.
"We have infrastructure that needs to be built before we can realize what economical development will come," he said of citizen advisory meetings looking at how light rail will come down Main Street. "Light rail is really important to us."
But focusing on opportunities in east Mesa, which is a transit boon for the entire community, Mayor Smith says is a necessity for improving transit options for the entire community.
"It is a real struggle to hold on to what we have," he said of drastic drops in sales-tax remits that typically pay for road maintenance and transit programs in Maricopa County. "That is a huge, huge concern. We simply don’t have the revenues, because of the economy, to to deliver services that we have been used to."
Councilman Scott Somers agrees dollars are limited for transit programs, which means those resources have to be properly divvied up.
"I suppose it is how you define what works the best," he said of mass-transit services offered in east Mesa, which his council district largely encompasses. "East Mesa is still emerging as a mass-transit center. What works the best for people in east Mesa is the use of their automobiles."
Because automobiles remain an east Mesa resident’s best transportation option, Councilman Somers says connectivity ought to be the end goal for current transit concerns.
"We need to continue to invest in our infrastructure," he explained. "As far as moving people, I think that we are seeing an incredible interest in mass-transit opportunities."
Regional transportation is a key component to moving people in and out of east Mesa, Councilman Somers says.
"What we need to work on for our transit system is a truly regional transit system. That is moving people to jobs and economic activity," he said. "That has to be regional, we have got to move away from parochial, localized self-interests."
While it could be slow coming, Councilman Somers remains steadfast to the assertion that mass-transit is the way of the future when it comes to moving Americans from "a" to "b."
"I think it is driven in part of the economy and in part by convenience. Why drive a car if mass transit can get you there?" he asked. "Each person is different and each person has a different reason for using mass transit."
Pinal County
In northern Pinal County, board of supervisors member Bryan Martyn says the bottom dollar will always dictate what transportation options are available to residents of unincorporated areas like San Tan Valley, but also in municipalities like Apache Junction.
"All of our transportation issues deal with quality of life," Supervisor Martyn said in a Dec. 9 phone interview. "Because the quality of life they are looking to improve, they have different levels of transportation."
Supervisor Martyn says transportation issues in northern Pinal County are varied.
"They don’t have the adequate infrastructure," he said of unincorporated areas of northern Pinal County. "How do I get a freeway to move back and forth? Those are quality-of-life issues."
The No. 1 priority to northern Pinal County — when it comes to transportation — is a major thoroughfare that most in the region are accustomed to driving.
"Hunt Highway remains the No. 1 priority in northern Pinal County," Supervisor Martyn said. "But how can we make it economically feasible to use a level of mass transit?"
Supervisor Martyn says everything is on the table when seeking funding for any type of transportation project in northern Pinal County.
"We are trying to find affordable solutions that work today and tomorrow," he explained. "But where is the money going to come from?"
Although mass-transit generally works, those types of services will be scarce, Supervisor Martyn contends. "We have already demonstrated the desire — I think ultimately it does come down to money — but you have got to have a car to get around."
Supervisor Martyn says northern Pinal County is chock-full of vacant land, and most who moved out that way sought open spaces, but now a balance has to be struck.
"We all have the open-space desire, but we all want the conveniences of the downtown," he pointed out. "Those do come down to money. We know it will be great to have light rail; everybody would love that, but that is billions of dollars nobody has."
How transportation funding is derived in Maricopa County works, but to do the same thing in Pinal County would be largely ineffective, Supervisor Martyn says.
"There are not enough taxpayers in Pinal County," he said of enlisting a half-percent levy on sales tax remits to pay for transportation projects. "You could, but I will tell you in Pinal County it is totally different than Maricopa county — it would take forever."
Comparing a population of roughly 350,000 to one in the millions, is like comparing apples to oranges, Supervisor Martyn says.
Apache Junction
"When you say transportation, I am thinking about roads and infrastructure," said Apache Junction Mayor John Insalaco in a Dec. 8 phone interview.
Mayor Insalaco says the future of transportation services — in addition to existing roads, streets and highways — is the pending State Route 802, but that could be 20 years away.
According to the Dec. 8 edition of the Apache Junction/Gold Canyon Independent, portions of the proposed freeway will eventually connect Loop 202 in Mesa to Ironwood Drive in unincorporated Pinal County south of the Williams Field Road alignment.
"As you know, state route 802 is coming and that will help," Mayor Insalaco said, but noting funding for the Pinal County portion is non existent. "I just hope that when it comes through it comes closer to Apache Junction."
Keeping what Apache Junction has in the ways of existing infrastructure is the name of the game, Mayor Insalaco says.
"We have got the roads we have got now, but we need to get that highway going," he explained. "But as far as a bus route coming out here, I don’t think we are ready for that."
Apache Junction resident Elliott Fisher agrees mass-transit services in his city are years out, but he would like to see city leaders take a proactive approach to developing infrastructure and the creation of some type of bus service.
"Well, transportation, in my estimation, is more than just moving people from place to place," Mr. Fisher said in a Dec. 9 phone interview. "I see the downtown of Apache Junction suffering because there are many people that are a one-car family."
Mr. Fisher says a seasonal circulating bus service and a link to the Superstition Springs Transit Center at the U.S. 60 and Power Road ought to be the focus of city leaders.
"For Pinal County to be claiming that they are concerned about multi-modal transportation, well, where is it?" he asked. "There are thousands and thousands of people in the far East Valley and they aren’t served by anything but a car."
Mr. Fisher says the youth of Apache Junction may be suffering the most when it comes to transportation options available in town.
"That is one of the problems for Apache Junction — the youth tend to get stranded," he said. "If they didn’t have to rely on parents, it may promote independence and promote a more viable downtown."
If Apache Junction wants to be anything more than a "second-class city" then it needs to start some type of push encouraging mass transit or innovative transportation options, Mr. Fisher says.
"I think it is just going to all-around improve the situation in Apache Junction," he said of mass-transit options. "I just can’t believe a couple of buses on a limited-schedule circulation in Apache Junction would be too costly."
But a circulating bus route is nothing new to the city of Apache Junction, Councilman Doug Coleman says.
"We did try an experiment back in 1995," he said of a trolley service based at Estes Park in Colorado. "They convinced us that (Apache Junction) would be a good place for them to spend the winter, but there were a lot of problems with it."
According to Councilman Coleman, the trolley service needed to maintain an average ridership of 100 patrons a day, but they averaged only three, which is why the pulled out after a six-month stint.
"They would average three, it was terrible," he said. "That part internally just doesn’t work."
Registered members are encouraged to comment on this topic by clicking “reply” in the upper right corner of this entry. Comments posted online may be used in an upcoming edition of the Mesa Independent. For more news, visit http://circulation.newszap.com to purchase an e-Subscription. As an e-Subscriber, you will be able to view the actual newspaper pages online, including every story, feature, advertisement and photo
|